BB8Dish is Watching - Are you?
Ready to Know What's Really Going on in the BB House?!
Click Here to Get Your
2 Week Free Trial of the Live Feeds!



CLICK THE HEADER TO CHECK FOR NEW BB8DISH UPDATES

Posts of Interest: Interview with Jessica's Mom, CBS Speaks Regarding Amber, C=Venus' Donatos T's!, Favorite Quotes of the Season, FUNNY - Who Would You?, The Nick Interview,
Who Shoulda Won?, Nick's New Ebay Stuff, Mike on Ebay,10 Minute Call with Howie!, America Votes @ Final 2!, Fess Up, America!, Live Feeds Replay!!, Donatos Tribute Video, Complete Endurance Comp Coverage, End & Post Comp Clips, The Interview with Eric's Bro, Josh

COOL BB STUFF:
Download Just Added CBS TV shows at iTunes,
Win Jen's "Jensa Member" Tank!, Win a Phone Call from Dustin, Custom Made BB8 Pillows!, Big Brother DVDs, Howie/Jerzeechik's All-Star Ebay Stuff,
Cool BB8 T-Shirts & More
Zach on Ebay, Eric on EBay, Jen's on Ebay!, Nick on Ebay, Daniele on EBay, Mike on Ebay,
Big Brother 8 Ebay Search Results

BB101:Answers to: What is 153?!? FSA??, How Does a Double Elimination Week Work?,
How the End Game Works


Click Here to Visit!

BB8Dish - Ya Gotta Have it!

SPOILER ALERT!! At bb8dish, we cover the live feeds. Much of what we write could be considered a spoiler for those who only watch the broadcast on CBS. Now, we don't understand why anyone would choose to do that, since it's like forming an opinion based on 1/10,000th of the information, and they could at least try the feeds for free, but what do we know?! Check bb8dish often for Updates, videos, pics, chops, opinions, etc. xoxo, C-n-C

Big Brother 8 is Finally Here!
Let the mind games begin!!

Watch Big Brother 8 on SuperPass!
Get the 2 Week Free Trial!
Click Here to join in the fun!



Click Here to Vote for America's Player

Click Here to Vote for Dick
to Get a Reality TV Award

Google

Monday, September 03, 2007

Not So Quickie Poll

Poll Created by Cliff

Every year there's a big debate over who won versus who "should have."

For each BB season save this one, if you don't think the "right" person won, what HGs would you have preferred to have seen come in first and second?


Click here to return to the top of the blog
Watch Big Brother 8 24/7 FREE for 2 Weeks!




40 Comments:

Blogger Shana May said...

season 7-Janelle
Season 6-Janelle
I saw season 5 but don't remember much (I was a tv only viewer :) So I dunno who should have won...
And that's it for me :)

6:30 PM  
Anonymous Tatodamy said...

I only watched the last two seasons...Janelle all the way!!!

6:34 PM  
Anonymous that guy said...

BB1...

Sucked. Didn't watch.


BB2...

1st - Will
2nd - Nicole


BB3...

1st - Roddy
2nd - Danielle


BB4...

1st - Scott
2nd - ^^ Kidding. This season was crap.


BB5...

1st - Nobody
2nd - Jase


BB6...

1st - Janelle
2nd - Who cares.


BB7...

1st - Janelle (target all season)
2nd - Will


BB8...

1st - Daniele
2nd - Dick

6:36 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

BB1- watched 1st couple of episode but sucked

BB2- saw one episode so don't know
BB3- didn't see any
BB4- saw a couple but not enough to know the houseguests

BB5- Aiden or Drew
BB6- Janelle or Kayser
BB7- Janelle or James

BB8- Eric or Dick

6:42 PM  
Anonymous that guy said...

Looking back on all the seasons, it's funny how there were quite a few "Nerd Herds" (all coming after season 4), with some having more success than others.

BB4..
Jun, Dana, Jee, Justin, & Robert

BB5..
Diane, Nakomis, Karen, & Will

BB6..
April, Beau, Eric, Ivette, Jennifer, & Maggie

BB8..
Dustin, Amber, Jameka, Eric, & Jessica

6:47 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

I wish Britney would have won Season 1 .. she was my favorite BB player :-)

And I would have LOVED to see Jani win because she kicked some BB butt :-)

6:50 PM  
Anonymous MoNYC said...

Season 7: Will
Season 6: Janelle
Season 4 & 5: Don't care and don't remember
Season 3: Danielle
Those are all I've seen.

6:51 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Seasons 2 - 4 didnt watch.
Season 5 Diane or Jase
Season 6 Janelle or James
Season 7 Janelle of Will
Season 8 - I want Eric or Jess to win but that doesnt look like it happening so i guess dick should win.

6:55 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

I have never watched until this season. I LOVE JESSICA and think she should win. BUT I also think Danielle has played the game the best

6:57 PM  
Anonymous Wondermutt said...

Who should have won...

1 - didn't watch

2 - Will

3 - Roddy

4 - Alison

5 - Diane

6 - Janelle

7 - Will

8 - Dani (should win)

7:00 PM  
Anonymous laci said...

BB4 was my first season, so here we go...

BB4: 1st-Erika, 2nd-Jee
BB5: 1st-Nakomis, 2nd-Drew
BB6: 1st-Janelle, 2nd-who cares
BB7: 1st-Will, 2nd-Janelle
BB8: 1st-Dick, 2nd-Eric

7:03 PM  
Anonymous Mikey STL 72 said...

We're talking BB8 - right?

Here's who I'd like to see win:
1st - Eric (he had obstacles to overcome that no one else had to + play the game)

2nd - Daniele played the game (once Nick left) as strategic as possible and is using her father for all he is worth.

7:08 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Sigh, Kaysar was one of the worst big brother players in the history of the show. When will people come to understand this? He has been evicted 3 times in a total of like 8 weeks i think.

Season 1:
Chicken George. The guy who won, did so becuase of a pity vote, i am not afraid to say it.

Season 2:
WILL. Greatest Big Brother player ever

Season 3:
Roddy: very close but not the whole way. danielle a close second this season.

Season 4:
Worst Season ever, i dont want ANY of them to win

Season 5:
Nakomis: Tough call, but i will say nakomis. Marvin and Jase fell early and Drew played a solid game, though boring.

Season 6:
Maggie: one of the most overrated players in reality show history. people dont give her credit becuase everyone was on a Jannelle high for some reason. Maggie was a true puppetmaster, 2nd best (after will of course) the show has seen.

Season 7:
Dr. Will. Best player in Big Brother History. But i feel like Mike winning is almost as good as Will becuase they were a pair from day 1 to the end.

Season 8:
Dick. Come on Dick! constantly a target, in peoples faces and manages to keep his head above water week after week.

7:11 PM  
Anonymous lanie said...

Danielle should have won Season 3 and Chicken George should have won BB All Stars. Of course Janelle should have won the nerd herd year.

7:12 PM  
Anonymous MICHAEL said...

ahhh i didnt think id ever have to think about eric and maggie ever again.. they really made me sick.. Kaysar all the way except he didnt do well in all stars..

7:22 PM  
Blogger erin said...

janelle should have one season 6 and 7

7:24 PM  
Blogger Carolyn said...

michael - ditto on maggie..

7:31 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

I watched season one, but I can't remember the players.

BB6: Janelle or James
BB7: 1. Janelle & 2. Will
BB8: 1. Dani & 2. Dick

7:32 PM  
Blogger Cliff O'Neill said...

Lovin' that Carolyn used my suggestion for this poll.

Sooo here's mine ..

BB1: (win) Britney, (place) Curtis
BB2: (win) Nicole, (place) Will
BB3: (win) Danielle (place) Amy or Roddy
BB4: (win) Jun (same, I know), (place) Jack
BB5: (ugh, no one really, but for giggles) (win) Natalie (place) Adria
BB6: (win) Janelle (c'mon!) (place) Kayser
BB7: (win) Janelle (again.) (place) Danielle

BB8: Considering I'm going to be in pain yet again -- even Jun's win in BB4 was so unsatisfactory -- I'm just gonna be contrary and say ...

(win) King Dusty (place) Joe (just to watch him lose his mind at that outcome)

As much as he was a huge poopiehead and nimrod par excellance, you gotta admit that that would be memorable TV.

7:40 PM  
Blogger Cliff O'Neill said...

Oh yeah, and then spend the last night in the house having loud angry hate sex in the HOH.

C'mon America! It woulda been mind-warping on so many levels!

7:44 PM  
Blogger Kristin said...

BB1 - Eddie
BB2 - Will
BB3 - Jason
BB4 - Jun (I guess... I hated this season...)
BB5 - Jase or Drew
BB6 - Janelle
BB7 - Will
BB8 - Daniele

7:53 PM  
Blogger Evel Girl said...

Cliff- LMAO. I wonder if Dustin would have to keep the crown on?

7:56 PM  
Blogger Ashley said...

Season 1 - 1st Brittany 2nd Eddie
Season 2 - (Remember when Mike asked Krista to marry him?)
Nicole (1)Will(2)
Seasom 3 - Marcellas(1) Amy (2)
Season 4 - Jun (1) Jack (2)
Season 5 - Nakomis (1) Diane (2)
Season 6-7 didn't watch
Season 8 Dick (1) Dani (2)

8:54 PM  
Blogger Kimberly said...

BB3...

1. Danielle

Of all the seasons, this is the one that still pisses me off to no end. Danielle played that game hard. And she was screwed out of a win because the jury couldn't get past their own pettiness and hurt feelings to award the best player the win. Lisa will always be the Pet Rock of BB to me.

9:14 PM  
Blogger Todd said...

My should-have-wons:

Season 1: Who cares?

Season 2: Will. Still the greatest player in the history of the show.

Season 3: Danielle. Played beautifully until she got screwed by the diary room. Still a big shame she lost.

Season 4: Jack. He always alligned himself well and was just an overall nice guy. He was never gonna win though, because who in that house would want to be sitting next to him in the final 2?

Season 5: Nakomis. She heard the rules, saw a loophole and exploited it to perfection. Probably the smartest player in BB history. Now if she could just talk the season 8 folks to stop using it so much.

Season 6: Janelle. Even after the collapse of her alliance (thanks Howie), she still managed to convince the other side she wasn't as big a threat as that dolt. Plus I'll always stick with someone who picked the person in the end that played the better game. Sorry, but Maggie sucked and Ivette should have won. Oh well.

Season 7: Will. He's the only former winner in a house full of the "greatest" players in BB history and someone he still manages to convince them to keep him in the house? To all those who answered Janelle here, do you really think she should have won when she let herself get manipulated by the guy that coined the term showmance?

Season 8: No one. This may be the worst group of players since season 4. Eric never really caught onto playing our game, Dick's not even trying (he's like Will without all the charmisma and likability) and Danielle is hiding behind everyone's hatred of daddy. I'm rooting for Jessica, but to be honest, I could really care less. Wake me up when the new cast moves in.

9:42 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Season 1- I loved Eddie, but Josh should have won.
Season 2- Dr. Will
Season 3- Danielle/Jason (Lisa so did not deserve it)
Season 4- Didn't watch
Season 5- Didn't watch
Season 6- James/Kaysar (I'm NOT a Janie fan)
Season 7- Dr. Will (Again, I'm NOT a Janie fan)
Season 8- EvelDick/Daniele/Eric (And Eric only because AP made it difficult for him)

~jenn/jem925/EViLBiTCH

9:43 PM  
Blogger JudyD said...

Season 1-America's Choice-Eddie winner same
Josh runner up=Chicken George instead.

Season 2-Summer of Secrets-Will winner same
Nicole runner up same

Season 3-Lisa winner Danielle should have won
Danielle runner up should have been Marcellas

Season 4-X Factor-Jun winner Erika should have won
Alison runner up same

Season 5-Project DNA-Drew winner Nakomis should have won
Michael runner up same

Season 6-Pairs-Maggie winner Janelle should have won
Don't remember Kaysar instead

Season 7-All Stars- Mike winner
Janelle should have won
Runner up should have been Dr.Will

Season 8-Dick Winner
Daniele Runner up

9:46 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

does anyone think Danielle flirts with Zach in a wierd sort of way?...Or is it just me....

11:08 PM  
Blogger Stephen said...

Didn't watch season one

Season 2: Will baby!

Season 3: Was living in Europe so didn't see it, HOWEVER the season that was on in England that year was SO FUN!

Season 4: Was also out of the country living! :-(

Season 5: Jase

Season 6: Janelle.. she was not part of the herd and constantly was in a position of HAVING to win HOH and POV and got herself as far as she could...

Season 7: If not in Season 6, DEFINITLEY Season 7 (Season 7 was all about all stars and Janie is the biggest BB all star of all time... she was a target from day one and was constantly feeling her way through and scraping by week to week! Although if not Janie.. Boogie definitley deserved it!)

So far on Season 8, I really think Dani has done what it takes to be the best all around player and most deserving. While I am no where near her biggest fan, and even disliked her through some of the season, I feel that she has played the game the best, both stragetically and competition winning wise... she has kept her word unless absolutely necessary for her to break it and has repeatidly won competitions. She has alligned when she needed to, and broken alliances when she was getting the bum deal. I normally would have said Jessica for this season HOWEVER it was so stupid of her to go after Amber and Zach instead of backdooring Dani or Dick.. especially when her alliance member had the veto and ability to do so. That poor move is what did her in and she deserves to go home... as much as I hate to see her go! :-(

11:20 PM  
Blogger Christine Jean said...

what happened to the realdeal's account?

12:10 AM  
Anonymous MoNYC said...

Amen Kimberly, amen. I hold Danielle up there with Will and Janelle in the BB Hall of Fame. She is badass and she plays hard always!

4:57 AM  
Anonymous Tammy said...

Janelle should have won seasons 6&7.

5:26 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Season 4 - 1st Allison, 2nd Erika <-there the only two i remember
Season 5 - 1st Diane(man did i have a serious crush on her); 2nd Jase
Season 6 - Didn't care; although out of Ivette and Maggie, Ivette should have won
Season 7 - anyone but Mike
Season 8 - 1st Danielle, 2nd Dick

5:53 AM  
Blogger Evel Girl said...

Good Morning Carolyn!

6:19 AM  
Blogger Carolyn said...

Morning, EvelGirl :) I'm seriously in need of IV caffeine today.

6:33 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

ITA with Todd down below. But season 1 should have been Chicken George or Brit. And this yr, ANY of J/E/D/D cause they all played their OWN game :)


QUOTE:

Todd said...
My should-have-wons:

Season 1: Who cares?

Season 2: Will. Still the greatest player in the history of the show.

Season 3: Danielle. Played beautifully until she got screwed by the diary room. Still a big shame she lost.

Season 4: Jack. He always alligned himself well and was just an overall nice guy. He was never gonna win though, because who in that house would want to be sitting next to him in the final 2?

Season 5: Nakomis. She heard the rules, saw a loophole and exploited it to perfection. Probably the smartest player in BB history. Now if she could just talk the season 8 folks to stop using it so much.

Season 6: Janelle. Even after the collapse of her alliance (thanks Howie), she still managed to convince the other side she wasn't as big a threat as that dolt. Plus I'll always stick with someone who picked the person in the end that played the better game. Sorry, but Maggie sucked and Ivette should have won. Oh well.

Season 7: Will. He's the only former winner in a house full of the "greatest" players in BB history and someone he still manages to convince them to keep him in the house? To all those who answered Janelle here, do you really think she should have won when she let herself get manipulated by the guy that coined the term showmance?

Season 8: No one. This may be the worst group of players since season 4. Eric never really caught onto playing our game, Dick's not even trying (he's like Will without all the charmisma and likability) and Danielle is hiding behind everyone's hatred of daddy. I'm rooting for Jessica, but to be honest, I could really care less. Wake me up when the new cast moves in.

10:00 AM  
Anonymous that guy said...

Where's Carolyn's list??

11:14 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

so ...
season 1 - didnt watcch
seoson 2 - will
season 3 - jason or danielle
season 4 -alison
season 5 - diane
season 6 - janelle or kayser
season 7 - janie
season 8 - daniele

5:57 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Season 1: Chicken George
Season 2: Dr. Evil
Season 3: LISA
Season 4: JUSTIN
Season 5: Drew
Season 6: Janelle
Season 7: Janelle....Dr. Delicious
Season 8: Jensa!

2:33 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

1- Eddie. Check. (George- with his "they want us to walk out- that's how we all win" strategy? gimme a break. The guy was sweet but nuts).
2- Will. Check.
3. Danielle. Was this the Bunky/Kent season? I liked their unlikely pairing.
Can't keep the seasons straight though, they were all boring for awhile... hated Lisa, hate Scott & Jase, hated Allison, hated Diane, the Cowboy and Nakomis reunion was anticlimactic, and somewhere that gets us up to...

BB6: James. Has everyone forgotten what a veto monster he was? And a great manipulator... loved to hate him- he was Will Jr. I liked Kaysar but he was a weak player- can't believe he took his hand off the button!! Janelle- came on strong, I liked her, but she let Howie do her dirty work yelling at April etc. I don't get the Janelle obsession, but I'd take anyone over Maggie & the nerd herd.

All stars: Will- they were after him all season too- and they fell for his same tricks as S2! Amazing he charmed them again, with an open Chilltown alliance no less. Janelle- close second. Or maybe Janelle first and Will 2nd since Janelle actually bothered to compete. Erika was useless- I felt bad watching her get manipulated. Never in control. Boogie, horrifying, disgusting, hated that he won. That season's final 4 had the wrong final 2.

8- Dick. Had Jessica still been in the house I think the evictees would have liked to pick her- sweet/no enemies, but also perceived as having a game vs. floating like Jameka. I'd be curious to see what they would have done with Zach at the end.

Ok, sorry, too long, but there ya go.

11:27 PM  

Post a Comment

<< Home